Does it matter which one you report? There is more than one possible method to compute R^2. Worse, there are ways to compute an adjusted R^2, which is sometimes arguably more appropriate. So you might be just seeing an adjusted R^2.
Or it might be simply that you extracted a set of coefficients without taking ALL of the significant digits of those parameters, putting essentially the wrong results into Excel. This is a common mistake in fact.
Don't get hung up on a single number that tries to predict goodness of fit. R^2 simply is not that important.
