Why, oh why does isempty return 0? Questions related to dataset access and return from strfind.

2 views (last 30 days)
Hello all,
I have a dataset array for example called measurement which contains a subfield called tempSequence containing single digits stored as strings (eg. '1', '2', etc.) I want to perform a check for the contents of this field and am using a combination of isempty and strfind and can't seem to get a TRUE return.
Specifically, I want to check that the field contains both a '1' and a '5' like so:
if( ~isempty(strfind(measurement.TempSequence, '1')) && isempty(strfind(messung.TempSequence, '5')) )
% Both 1 and 5 are present, perform operation on different subfield.
end
If tempSequence is as follows:
K>> measurement.TempSequence
ans =
'3'
'4'
'5'
'2'
And strfind returns:
K>> strfind(measurement.TempSequence, '1')
ans =
[]
[]
[]
[]
Why why why:
K>> isempty(strfind(measurement.TempSequence, '1'))
ans =
0
Is it something to do with it being a dataset and therefore has attached metadata? Am I using strfind in a dumb way? What am I missing?
Why:
K>> isempty(strfind(measurement.TempSequence, 'foobar'))
ans =
0
Thank you for reading! Marshall

Accepted Answer

Matt J
Matt J on 29 Sep 2014
Edited: Matt J on 29 Sep 2014
The output of strfind is a cell array. To be considered empty, a cell array must have no cells whatsoever,
>> isempty({})
ans =
1
This is different from a cell array containing cells with empty matrices
>> c={[]};
>> isempty(c)
ans =
0
>> isempty(c{1})
ans =
1

More Answers (2)

Stephen23
Stephen23 on 29 Sep 2014
Edited: Stephen23 on 29 Sep 2014
Expanding on Matt J's answer, if you wish to check if every cell of a cell array contains an empty array, then you can use cellfun :
cellfun('isempty',cell_array)
  2 Comments
Marshall
Marshall on 30 Sep 2014
Ah, thanks! I'm coming from embedded C so vector operations and so on are all very new territory for me.
Stephen23
Stephen23 on 30 Sep 2014
It is a good thing that you keep this in mind. Basically in MATLAB think of the arrays/matrices more as the mathematical concept, and not as a programming abstraction of some lower-level data (like in C).

Sign in to comment.


David Young
David Young on 29 Sep 2014
The two earlier answers are both correct. Another suggestion which might help is to use ismember() instead of ~isempty(strfind()), with the opposite argument ordering:
if ismember('1', measurement.TempSequence) && ismember('5', measurement.TempSequence)
...
  2 Comments
Marshall
Marshall on 30 Sep 2014
Great suggestion. I think it's cleaner and reads better too. I'm coming from embedded C to OO MatLab so it's a steep learning curve!
Thanks for the help.
Marshall
Marshall on 30 Sep 2014
Edited: Marshall on 30 Sep 2014
ismember is the sort of function I was looking for in the first place, but there's such a huge number of functions to learn (but so it is with all languages). Your suggestion worked perfectly. So glad for this rad community. M_

Sign in to comment.

Categories

Find more on Characters and Strings in Help Center and File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!