unexpected value for nargout when returning a class/struct

4 views (last 30 days)
What values for nargout would you expect for the last two lines in the run block: 0 or 1?
Class A
classdef A < handle
methods
function r=fctA(~)
disp(['nargout=' num2str(nargout)])
r=B;
end
end
end
Class B
classdef B < handle
methods
function fctB(~,~)
end
end
end
run
a=A;
a.fctA.fctB;
a.fctA.fctB(1);
  2 Comments
Matt J
Matt J on 10 Jun 2014
Edited: Matt J on 10 Jun 2014
I think the bigger surprise is that you can directly dot-index the output of a function call. Since when has that been possible????
Markus Leuthold
Markus Leuthold on 10 Jun 2014
Edited: Markus Leuthold on 10 Jun 2014
it only works with methods from new-style classes (classdef). Following code doesn't work, as you've expected:
function r=fcn
r.value=1;
end
this won't work
fcn.value
Even worse, this code crashes Matlab:
function matlabcrash
mytest.value
function a=mytest
a.value=1;
end
end
So I'm asking myself if dot-index the output of a method is illegal as well and only works by coincidence?

Sign in to comment.

Answers (1)

Philip Borghesani
Philip Borghesani on 11 Jun 2014
Edited: Philip Borghesani on 11 Jun 2014
In general you cannot index into the output of a function call in MATLAB.
You have found an under documented feature of dot indexing on objects and a bug in that feature. The ability to index into the output of a dot function call on MATLAB class objects leaked into a previous version. This ability has always existed for Java objects. Because this feature just worked in many places it has been frequently exploited in MATLAB code and removing it would be quite difficult making supporting it necessary. In general we believe that the following code is more conformant MATLAB code for calling a method and will have similar performance:
a=A;
Bobj=fctA(a);
fctB(Bobj);
Nargout in your example code should be 1 and this is fixed in a future version of MATLAB. Note that a.fctA().fctB also returns 1.
I have entered a bug report for the crash with a nested function but I would not expect that code to be legal MATLAB code in the foreseeable future.
Information stated here is not an official guarantee of support or statement of policy from MathWorks.

Categories

Find more on Argument Definitions in Help Center and File Exchange

Products

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!